Replacing vs. Refacing Cabinets: Which is Cheaper?

Kitchen cabinets are one of the most important parts of any kitchen. They provide storage, define the kitchen’s style, and affect the overall functionality of the space. However, as cabinets age, they can become worn out, damaged, or outdated.

The choice between replacing and refacing cabinets depends on several factors, including your budget, the condition of the existing cabinets, and your design preferences.

This article will explore the differences between replacing, refacing, and refinishing cabinets, compare their costs, and provide tips for choosing the most cost-effective solution.

What Is Cabinet Replacement?

Cabinet replacement involves completely removing your existing cabinets and installing brand-new ones. This is the best option if your cabinets are structurally damaged or poorly designed or if you want to completely change the kitchen layout. Since it requires removing and replacing the entire cabinet structure, replacement is the most expensive and time-consuming option.

Pros of Replacing Cabinets

1. Since installing new cabinets, you can choose any design, colour, or material that suits your style.
2. full cabinet replacement increases home value and attracts potential buyers, especially if you use high-quality materials.

Cost of Replacing Cabinets

The total cost of replacing cabinets depends on the materials, style, and labour costs. Here’s an estimate:

• Stock cabinets (pre-made, limited styles): $3,000–$8,000
• Semi-custom cabinets (some modifications allowed): $8,000–$15,000

The cost of a complete kitchen makeover with new countertops, backsplashes, and flooring could exceed $30,000.

What Is Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing is a cost-effective way to give your kitchen a fresh look without removing the existing cabinet structure. Instead of replacing the entire cabinet, refacing involves replacing the cabinet doors, drawer fronts, and hardware while keeping the original cabinet boxes. A thin veneer (wood or laminate) is applied to the cabinet exteriors to match the new doors.

Pros of Refacing Cabinets

1. Refacing costs significantly less than replacing cabinets, making it a budget-friendly option.
2. Since the cabinet boxes remain intact, refacing can be completed in 3–5 days.

Cost of Refacing Cabinets

The cost of cabinet refacing depends on materials and labour. On average, refacing costs:

• Laminate veneer refacing: $4,000–$7,000
• Real wood veneer refacing: $6,000–$9,000

Refacing costs less than full replacement but is still a major expense compared to simple refinishing.

What Is Cabinet Refinishing?

Cabinet refinishing is the most affordable way to refresh kitchen cabinets. It involves sanding down the existing cabinets and applying new paint, stain, or finish to make them look new. Refinishing is ideal if your cabinets are in good structural condition but have surface wear, discolouration, or outdated finishes.

Pros of Refinishing Cabinets

1. Refinishing is the most budget-friendly way to upgrade cabinets, especially if you do it yourself.
2. If you like your current cabinet style and layout, refinishing allows you to preserve them while improving their appearance.

Cost of Refinishing Cabinets

• DIY refinishing: $200–$600 (for paint, brushes, sandpaper, and tools)
• Professional refinishing: $1,500–$4,000 (for labour and materials)

Refinishing is the best option for homeowners looking to refresh their cabinets at the lowest possible cost.

Cheapest Ways to Reface Kitchen Cabinets

If you decide to reface your cabinets, here are some ways to cut costs:

1. Use Laminate Instead of Real Wood Veneer: Laminate veneers cost less and are more durable.
2. Opt for Stock or Pre-Made Doors: Custom cabinet doors increase costs significantly.
3. DIY Preparation Work: Remove cabinet doors and clean surfaces before hiring professionals.
4. Reuse Hardware: Keeping existing knobs and hinges can save you money.
5. Compare Contractor Quotes: Getting multiple estimates helps find the best deal.

Conclusion:

Refacing is the best cost-effective option if your cabinets are still in good condition but look outdated. It provides a fresh look without the high cost of full replacement. If you are on a very tight budget, refinishing with paint or stain is the cheapest way to refresh your kitchen.

On the other hand, replacing is the best choice if your cabinets are structurally damaged or if you want a completely new layout, but it comes at a much higher cost. By carefully considering your budget and needs, you can choose the right solution and give your kitchen a new look without overspending.